Judge Voids Decision after Racist Comments Revealed
Unexpected things can always happen in divorce court, but you usually don’t expect the judge to make a racist comment resulting in a legal error that can change the entire case. A judge in Pennsylvania has been accused of racism after several remarks he made during a child support hearing.
The man in the case, Kostas “Gus” Hartas, is Greek. He said that the judge, Michael Coll, accused him of not paying his child support because of his ethnicity. According to court transcripts, the following exchange occurred:
Coll: “Are you of Greek background sir?”
Hartas: “Yes sir.”
Coll: “Right, the Greeks never pay taxes.”
Hartas’ attorney objected.
Coll: “That’s why their country is in bankruptcy.”
Again, Hartas’ attorney objected
Coll: “So can I take judicial note of the fact that the Greeks are in bankruptcy as a nation and one of the reasons, the principal reason is because none of them ever pay taxes?”
Hartas’ attorney continued to object until the judge said “Well, these are simply statements of fact, right?”
According to Hartas, his mother was reduced to tears at the judge’s statements. Hartas has lived in the US since he was 3 years old.
The judge apologized to NBC10, but Hartas is demanding an in-person apology. Coll has also vacated the child support order signed at the hearing and ordered a new hearing with a different judge. However, he has not faced any disciplinary actions yet.
When something shocking like this occurs, you need a lawyer on your side. Hartas’ lawyer did the right thing. Courts must be fair to the litigants in front of them or they lose all legitimacy and cultural bias as so place in the court. When a judge lets personal feelings sway their decisions, lawyers must be ready to call them out on it.
Most lawyers and judges know better. Personal feelings cannot get in the way of the legal process if it is to remain fair. At Elise Buie Family Law Group, PLLC, we will argue the facts of the case and the laws of the State of Washington to the judge if your divorce case goes to trial. Call our office today to schedule a consultation.
STAY UP TO DATE
Subscribe to our newsletters
Subscribe to one or more of our newsletters, delivering meaningful insight on topics that matter to you and your family.
If you ask those who have survived domestic violence why they stayed in abusive situations as long as they did, it is often not because they did not realize that what was happening to them was abuse. People who have…
A prenuptial agreement, or a “prenup,” can help you and your future spouse decide how to handle certain financial issues in your lives before they cause conflict and hurt feelings. This is true even if you believe you would never…
Judge Voids Decision after Racist Comments Revealed
Unexpected things can always happen in divorce court, but you usually don’t expect the judge to make a racist comment resulting in a legal error that can change the entire case. A judge in Pennsylvania has been accused of racism after several remarks he made during a child support hearing.
The man in the case, Kostas “Gus” Hartas, is Greek. He said that the judge, Michael Coll, accused him of not paying his child support because of his ethnicity. According to court transcripts, the following exchange occurred:
Coll: “Are you of Greek background sir?”
Hartas: “Yes sir.”
Coll: “Right, the Greeks never pay taxes.”
Hartas’ attorney objected.
Coll: “That’s why their country is in bankruptcy.”
Again, Hartas’ attorney objected
Coll: “So can I take judicial note of the fact that the Greeks are in bankruptcy as a nation and one of the reasons, the principal reason is because none of them ever pay taxes?”
Hartas’ attorney continued to object until the judge said “Well, these are simply statements of fact, right?”
According to Hartas, his mother was reduced to tears at the judge’s statements. Hartas has lived in the US since he was 3 years old.
The judge apologized to NBC10, but Hartas is demanding an in-person apology. Coll has also vacated the child support order signed at the hearing and ordered a new hearing with a different judge. However, he has not faced any disciplinary actions yet.
When something shocking like this occurs, you need a lawyer on your side. Hartas’ lawyer did the right thing. Courts must be fair to the litigants in front of them or they lose all legitimacy and cultural bias as so place in the court. When a judge lets personal feelings sway their decisions, lawyers must be ready to call them out on it.
Most lawyers and judges know better. Personal feelings cannot get in the way of the legal process if it is to remain fair. At Elise Buie Family Law Group, PLLC, we will argue the facts of the case and the laws of the State of Washington to the judge if your divorce case goes to trial. Call our office today to schedule a consultation.
STAY UP TO DATE
Subscribe to our newsletters
FURTHER READING
Latest Blog Posts
Domestic Violence: Legal Protections and Resources for Victims
If you ask those who have survived domestic violence why they stayed in abusive situations as long as they did, it is often not because they did not realize that what was happening to them was abuse. People who have…
How to Find the Right Collaborative Divorce Lawyer for Your Case
Learn from a Seattle family law attorney how to find the right collaborative divorce lawyer for your Washington state divorce.
5 Benefits of Collaborative Divorce Over Litigation
Learn from an experienced Seattle divorce lawyer about the benefits of collaborative divorce over litigation.
Collaborative Divorce vs. Divorce Mediation
A skilled and experienced Seattle family law attorney describes the differences between collaborative divorce and divorce mediation.
When You Have No One to Trust for Key Roles in Your Estate Plan
A Seattle estate planning attorney can help guide you about who to choose for key roles in your estate plan.
The Smart Couple’s Guide to Prenuptial Agreements
A prenuptial agreement, or a “prenup,” can help you and your future spouse decide how to handle certain financial issues in your lives before they cause conflict and hurt feelings. This is true even if you believe you would never…
When Negotiations Break Down in a Collaborative Divorce
A skilled and experienced Seattle family law attorney describes what happens when negotiations break down in a collaborative divorce.
Simplifying Single Parenting: Tips and Tricks
A skilled and experienced Seattle family law attorney details tips and tricks for Washington state single parents.
Joint Tenancy vs. Co-Tenancy for Unmarried Couples in Washington
A Seattle estate planning attorney can guide unmarried couples who plan on owning real property together in Washington state.
What Is an Ethical Will?
A Seattle estate planning attorney can guide you on using transfer-on-death deeds to avoid probate in Washington state.